"Carbon offsetting" stinks...

[AE-NMidlands]

as I have always suspected: https://www.theguardian.com/environment ... vation-aoe

We don’t know where the money is going’: the ‘carbon cowboys’ making millions from credit schemes
Carbon schemes are touted as a way to transfer billions in climate finance to the developing world – but people at the Kariba project in Zimbabwe say most of the profits never arrive.
In the districts surrounding Lake Kariba in Zimbabwe, most people have little idea their villages were at the centre of a multimillion-dollar carbon boom. Punctuated by straw-thatched mud houses, the Miombo woodlands on the edge of the enormous artificial lake are mostly home to smallholder farmers. The gravel roads are full of potholes; cars are infrequent, as are medical facilities and internet connections. Data on the region is patchy, but Hurungwe district, that covers a number of the villages has an average poverty rate of 88%.
These communities fall within the vast, lucrative Kariba conservation project, encompassing an area almost the size of Puerto Rico. It is among the largest in a portfolio of forest offsetting schemes approved by Verra, the world’s largest certifier. Since 2011, this project alone has generated revenue of more than €100m (£85m) from selling carbon credits equivalent to Kenya’s 2022 national emissions to western companies, according to now-deleted figures published by the project developer. Proponents say these schemes are a quick way of transferring billions of dollars of climate and biodiversity finance to the developing world through company net zero pledges.
More than a decade on from the project’s inception, however, many local people say the projects and infrastructure they anticipated never emerged. Only a fraction of the €100m has been distributed to the villages within the project.
‘We are not seeing money trickle down’

“Surely a reward must come,” says Rogers Kavura, a 46-year-old who lives in Chikova village in Hurungwe district. He became a forest ranger with the local council, funded by the offsetting project.
Rogers Kavura, a forest ranger in Chikova village in Hurungwe, says the community would like to see improvements to roads, schools, health and irrigation.

“We hear reports that the company has been making lots of money, but we do not know where this money is going. The community is complaining because they are not seeing money trickle down,” Kavura says.

and so on (depressingly, but not surprisingly)

[nowty]

Thats why I believe the only worthwhile carbon offsetting schemes are closer to home, like your own home solar PV or other cooperative Solar, Wind and Hydro schemes.

They are tangible, you can visit them, you can measure them, you can get involved, you can see their accounts, there are local benefits, etc.

[Joeboy]

Same thing happened in Nigeria with the oil money. Most of it was siphoned off by Govt. Plenty more was chopped up in projects that went nowhere (including motorway stretches that don't connect at either end). I remember laughing with some local lads as the last guy in power back then had siphoned $46 billion+ according to the lads. They were pissing themselves laughing at the level of corruption they were surrounded by.

Sadly it seems to be human nature to feed the greed and damn the consequences for all others.

Do what you can, where YOU can. Works for me!

Hoping to get up to Kinlochbervie next week to see the burn at least and the pump house.

[GarethC]

Thing is, contributing to building an industrial solar PV farm in oil burning Nigeria or a wind farm in coal burning Poland has a far bigger environmental bang for your buck than contributing to a wind turbine in gas burning, frequently constrained UK.

If, and it's a big if, a robust regulatory regime can be constructed, carbon offsetting can be a major force for good.