Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

If there is a foul wind a blowin' then drop by for a chat - about coconuts of anything else off topic.
Oldgreybeard
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2021 3:42 pm
Location: North East Dorset

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#21

Post by Oldgreybeard »

Fintray wrote: Sat Sep 10, 2022 10:30 am As the CO2 cylinders (from BOC) have a maximum pressure of 50 Bar, I would imagine that the regulators have a different fitting to prevent anyone trying to use the regulators on any of the other higher pressure (up to 300 Bar) gasses.
That makes sense. I have a distant memory of there being thread differences between different gases, too. I had a small oxyacetylene welding set years ago and I'm sure that the threads were reversed so that the oxygen regulator couldn't be accidentally screwed on to the acetylene bottle.

I've decided to play around with getting finer CO2 bubbles into the water, so have ordered a stainless steel "carbonation stone". This should get more CO2 into the water at lower pressures, so may speed up the process a bit.
25 off 250W Perlight solar panels, installed 2014, with a 6kW PowerOne inverter, about 6,000kWh/year generated
6 off Pylontech US3000C batteries, with a Sofar ME3000SP inverter
User avatar
Fintray
Posts: 1526
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 6:37 pm
Location: Aberdeenshire

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#22

Post by Fintray »

Oldgreybeard wrote: Sat Sep 10, 2022 10:43 am
Fintray wrote: Sat Sep 10, 2022 10:30 am As the CO2 cylinders (from BOC) have a maximum pressure of 50 Bar, I would imagine that the regulators have a different fitting to prevent anyone trying to use the regulators on any of the other higher pressure (up to 300 Bar) gasses.
That makes sense. I have a distant memory of there being thread differences between different gases, too. I had a small oxyacetylene welding set years ago and I'm sure that the threads were reversed so that the oxygen regulator couldn't be accidentally screwed on to the acetylene bottle.
That's correct the fuel gas threads are all L/H whilst oxygen is R/H.
3.87kWp PV
10.24kWp PV SolarEdge system
Tesla Powerwall 2
100 x 47mm Navitron tubes (still being installed!) Now likely to be removed for more PV.
MK2 PV router DHW diverter
Morso 5kW WBS
Vaillant AroTherm 10kW ASHP
Nissan Leaf
Swwils
Posts: 547
Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2022 12:58 pm

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#23

Post by Swwils »

Make sure you buy food grade gas not gas for welding.
Oldgreybeard
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2021 3:42 pm
Location: North East Dorset

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#24

Post by Oldgreybeard »

Swwils wrote: Sat Sep 10, 2022 12:36 pm Make sure you buy food grade gas not gas for welding.
This seems to be an interesting point, as I've spoken with our local gas distributor and the chap there has told me that there is no difference and that all their CO2 comes from the same source. They refill bottles on site and no matter what the bottle is going to be used for it gets filled with the same CO2. From what I've read the only difference between "food grade" and any other gas cylinder (like those used with aquariums, paintball guns, MIG welding, etc) is that the cylinders are cleaned internally after manufacture, so there's less likely to be manufacturing dust/particles left inside them.

At the moment I'm using a MIG welding gas cylinder, really because that was the cheapest way to knock up a rig to see how well it works. Lots of others into the DIY carbonation thing seem to also use these cylinders. They aren't that good in terms of value, but are still a lot cheaper than using Sodastream cylinders. The plan is to get a 6.35kg pub gas bottle for the permanent setup. They cost about £92 initially, then £36 per refill, which works out to about 4p/litre of carbonated water. Bit better than the 38p/litre for the Sodastream.
25 off 250W Perlight solar panels, installed 2014, with a 6kW PowerOne inverter, about 6,000kWh/year generated
6 off Pylontech US3000C batteries, with a Sofar ME3000SP inverter
User avatar
nowty
Posts: 5749
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 2:36 pm
Location: South Coast

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#25

Post by nowty »

Sodastream nostalgia, I think this is from 1979, I still remember something weird happened the third time Tommy Cooper pressed the button.


Always wanted one, but never bothered because of the cost. I drink at least two litres of supermarket bottled fizzy water per day which is under 20p a litre but it does concern me about my plastic footprint. :?

There is a simple how to guide here, (method 3) which aligns to Oldgreybeard's method.
https://www.wikihow.com/Carbonate-a-Beverage

Its doing my head in as you have to shake it to get the CO2 in when normally when you shake a fizzy drink it comes out. :oops:
Last edited by nowty on Sat Sep 10, 2022 2:00 pm, edited 2 times in total.
16.9kW PV > 109MWh generated
Ripple 6.6kW Wind + 4.5kW PV > 25MWh generated
5 Other RE Coop's
105kWh EV storage
60kWh Home battery storage
40kWh Thermal storage
GSHP + A2A HP's
Rain water use > 510 m3
AE-NMidlands
Posts: 2011
Joined: Wed Jun 02, 2021 6:10 pm

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#26

Post by AE-NMidlands »

Oldgreybeard wrote: Sat Sep 10, 2022 12:51 pm
Swwils wrote: Sat Sep 10, 2022 12:36 pm Make sure you buy food grade gas not gas for welding.
This seems to be an interesting point, as I've spoken with our local gas distributor and the chap there has told me that there is no difference and that all their CO2 comes from the same source. They refill bottles on site and no matter what the bottle is going to be used for it gets filled with the same CO2. From what I've read the only difference between "food grade" and any other gas cylinder (like those used with aquariums, paintball guns, MIG welding, etc) is that the cylinders are cleaned internally after manufacture, so there's less likely to be manufacturing dust/particles left inside them.

At the moment I'm using a MIG welding gas cylinder, really because that was the cheapest way to knock up a rig to see how well it works. Lots of others into the DIY carbonation thing seem to also use these cylinders. They aren't that good in terms of value, but are still a lot cheaper than using Sodastream cylinders. The plan is to get a 6.35kg pub gas bottle for the permanent setup. They cost about £92 initially, then £36 per refill, which works out to about 4p/litre of carbonated water. Bit better than the 38p/litre for the Sodastream.
A very deep-thinking engineer friend asked me about this when I had access to some British Standards, as he was thinking of using his welding CO2 for carbonation too (probably just blanketing a beer keg actually.) I couldn't get hold of the right ones but later he told me that he had discovered that the difference between welding and food-grade gas was the permitted humidity. Welding gas had to be a lot drier apparently.
A
2.0 kW/4.62 MWh pa in Ripples, 4.5 kWp W-facing pv, 9.5 kWh batt
30 solar thermal tubes, 2MWh pa in Stockport, plus Congleton and Kinlochbervie Hydros,
Most travel by bike, walking or bus/train. Veg, fruit - and Bees!
Oldgreybeard
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2021 3:42 pm
Location: North East Dorset

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#27

Post by Oldgreybeard »

The first time I tried this rig I charged a bottle of water to about 40psi, turned off the CO2, then shook the bottle and was amazed to see how much the pressure dropped as the CO2 was dissolved into the water. The pressure dropped right back to around 10psi with just a few seconds of shaking.

The idea behind trying a carbonation stone is to see if this removes the need to shake the bottle. I think it may, as in theory smaller bubbles of CO2 should make it dissolve more quickly, because of the much increased surface area of each bubble relative to its volume. The stainless carbonation stone I've ordered wasn't that expensive, about £8, and looks like this. It will fit on the end of the dip pipe that goes inside the bottle:

Image
25 off 250W Perlight solar panels, installed 2014, with a 6kW PowerOne inverter, about 6,000kWh/year generated
6 off Pylontech US3000C batteries, with a Sofar ME3000SP inverter
User avatar
nowty
Posts: 5749
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 2:36 pm
Location: South Coast

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#28

Post by nowty »

So shaking the bottle under high pressure gets the CO2 in the water and shaking already carbonated water at low pressure gets the CO2 out.

The paradox is fixed, my heads better now. :D
16.9kW PV > 109MWh generated
Ripple 6.6kW Wind + 4.5kW PV > 25MWh generated
5 Other RE Coop's
105kWh EV storage
60kWh Home battery storage
40kWh Thermal storage
GSHP + A2A HP's
Rain water use > 510 m3
User avatar
SafetyThird
Posts: 201
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2022 11:32 am
Location: North Devon

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#29

Post by SafetyThird »

A friend of mine has a set up similar to OGB's but using industrial connectors and regulators. He has an entire lab and workshop as his job is engineering biochemical processes and equipment so built something himself.

We use a Sodastream and I now have an adaptor to go from a standard CO2 bottle to the sodastream. Just need to get a co2 bottle now. If you have a BOC type of pub bottle, where to you get them filled? Do you have to have an account with BOC or can they be taken to, for example, a welding place and refilled or would I need to find a friendly landlord to exchange them for me?

I know someone who has several short BOC CO2 bottles for setting up temporary beer pumps for events and could get one from them but not sure how I'd get it refilled easily.
6kw PV (24 x REC Solar AS REC 250PE)
Clausius 5-25kw GSHP
Luxpower Squirrel Pod
Pylontech 21kwh
Eddi Diverter
250l hot water tank with 2 immersions
2 x Woodwarm stoves
7 acres of old coppice woodland
Ripple Kirk Hill 3.8kw
Ripple Derril Water 3.963 kW
Oldgreybeard
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2021 3:42 pm
Location: North East Dorset

Re: Bodgineering - DIY carbonation

#30

Post by Oldgreybeard »

SafetyThird wrote: Sat Sep 10, 2022 3:03 pm A friend of mine has a set up similar to OGB's but using industrial connectors and regulators. He has an entire lab and workshop as his job is engineering biochemical processes and equipment so built something himself.

We use a Sodastream and I now have an adaptor to go from a standard CO2 bottle to the sodastream. Just need to get a co2 bottle now. If you have a BOC type of pub bottle, where to you get them filled? Do you have to have an account with BOC or can they be taken to, for example, a welding place and refilled or would I need to find a friendly landlord to exchange them for me?

I know someone who has several short BOC CO2 bottles for setting up temporary beer pumps for events and could get one from them but not sure how I'd get it refilled easily.
From looking around BOC are a bit of a pain as they still use a bottle rental scheme, so you need to pay a charge per month for the bottle. Other suppliers make a one-off deposit charge for the bottle, so there is no continuing payment. There are online suppliers, but they charge around £35 to £40 delivery for a 6.35kg/10 litre bottle.

https://www.bottlegases.co.uk/product-c ... ellar-gas/

https://gas-uk.co.uk/index.php/carbon-d ... litre.html

Locally I can buy CO2 from the local pub beer gas distributor. I just asked the landlady at my local where her gas came from and she gave me their number. I would guess that most places probably have a beer gas distributor fairly nearby. Only thing to watch with beer gas is that there are three or four different kinds of gas for beer. Some beers use a mix of CO2 and nitrogen, so you need to ask for pure CO2.

Another option might be to try Hobbyweld cylinders https://hobbyweld.co.uk/products/carbon ... ood-grade/ . Bit more expensive, but they seem to have a tie up with tool hire shops and they sell a dedicated CO2 beverage gas. Our local Sydenhams hire shop in Gillingham stocks Hobbyweld refills. You pay a deposit on the first bottle and then just pay the refill cost after that.
25 off 250W Perlight solar panels, installed 2014, with a 6kW PowerOne inverter, about 6,000kWh/year generated
6 off Pylontech US3000C batteries, with a Sofar ME3000SP inverter
Post Reply