ASHP & triple glazing

Air source, ground source and associated systems for heating homes
User avatar
Fintray
Posts: 1524
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 6:37 pm
Location: Aberdeenshire

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#281

Post by Fintray »

Joeboy wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 3:24 pm
Fintray wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 9:36 am
Joeboy wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 5:39 am

Did you go for the full mid metering? Any value in it?
I went MID metering as it is probably the most accurate available and will give you a true picture as to how your system is performing.
Thank you, I have asked for a price on the full bhuna. :D
The Openenergy monitor is MID metering.
3.87kWp PV
10.24kWp PV SolarEdge system
Tesla Powerwall 2
100 x 47mm Navitron tubes (still being installed!) Now likely to be removed for more PV.
MK2 PV router DHW diverter
Morso 5kW WBS
Vaillant AroTherm 10kW ASHP
Nissan Leaf
User avatar
Stinsy
Posts: 2748
Joined: Wed Jun 02, 2021 1:09 pm

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#282

Post by Stinsy »

Moxi wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 3:37 pm Reading this today sent me back to the heat pump monitoring pages to have another look and its surprising to see how flexible some of the set points are. As an example we were advised that running a heat pump low and slow is the best way to get the optimum performance, but on the monitor pages you can see that some pumps with very low flow temps of 35 to 39 degrees and 5kW Hp don't perform as well as say a system with a 45 degree flow temp and an 11kW Hp - so what is making the mid range capacity heat pumps with higher flow temps outperform the smaller ones ?

Moxi
Maybe it is the local environment? I’ve read that HPs in drier areas are more efficient than this in a very damp area. Outdoor temperature varies a lot between Scotland and Cornwall too.

Is there any way to find more about those very-efficient systems?
12x 340W JA Solar panels (4.08kWp)
3x 380W JA Solar panels (1.14kWp)
5x 2.4kWh Pylontech batteries (12kWh)
LuxPower inverter/charger

(Artist formally known as ******, well it should be obvious enough to those for whom such things are important.)
HML
Posts: 38
Joined: Sun Sep 03, 2023 1:56 pm

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#283

Post by HML »

Moxi wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 3:37 pm Reading this today sent me back to the heat pump monitoring pages to have another look and its surprising to see how flexible some of the set points are. As an example we were advised that running a heat pump low and slow is the best way to get the optimum performance, but on the monitor pages you can see that some pumps with very low flow temps of 35 to 39 degrees and 5kW Hp don't perform as well as say a system with a 45 degree flow temp and an 11kW Hp - so what is making the mid range capacity heat pumps with higher flow temps outperform the smaller ones ?

Moxi
There are loads of confounding variables and SPF isn't the be all and end all. (https://protonsforbreakfast.wordpress.c ... pointless/ for instance.)

One issue is defrosts. My heat pump is only just big enough and in cool damp weather (most of the winter) it defrosts frequently with a hit to SPF. A larger heat pump with a larger heat exchanger may defrost less frequently. Refrigerant makes a difference, R290 ones like the Vaillant Arotherm plus perform better at below 5C than most R32 heat pumps. Also those SPFs include hot water runs which are generally less efficient. A system with a lot of HW use is likely to perform worse than a system with low HW use.

A big factor is internal temperature. A system that runs at 19C is going to perform better than one that runs at 23C, all things being equal.

You need to look at systems very carefully in order to draw conclusions.
User avatar
Joeboy
Posts: 8013
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 4:22 pm
Location: Inverurie

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#284

Post by Joeboy »

HML wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 6:33 pm
Moxi wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 3:37 pm Reading this today sent me back to the heat pump monitoring pages to have another look and its surprising to see how flexible some of the set points are. As an example we were advised that running a heat pump low and slow is the best way to get the optimum performance, but on the monitor pages you can see that some pumps with very low flow temps of 35 to 39 degrees and 5kW Hp don't perform as well as say a system with a 45 degree flow temp and an 11kW Hp - so what is making the mid range capacity heat pumps with higher flow temps outperform the smaller ones ?

Moxi
There are loads of confounding variables and SPF isn't the be all and end all. (https://protonsforbreakfast.wordpress.c ... pointless/ for instance.)

One issue is defrosts. My heat pump is only just big enough and in cool damp weather (most of the winter) it defrosts frequently with a hit to SPF. A larger heat pump with a larger heat exchanger may defrost less frequently. Refrigerant makes a difference, R290 ones like the Vaillant Arotherm plus perform better at below 5C than most R32 heat pumps. Also those SPFs include hot water runs which are generally less efficient. A system with a lot of HW use is likely to perform worse than a system with low HW use.

A big factor is internal temperature. A system that runs at 19C is going to perform better than one that runs at 23C, all things being equal.

You need to look at systems very carefully in order to draw conclusions.
Excellent article (and post). I too am an idiot and particularly liked this paragraph,

"I think this result is both surprising and obvious. It’s counter-intuitive because in general a well-insulated home is easier to heat (with a heat pump or in any other way). But it is also quite obvious because the overall COP is the average of the DHW COP and space-heating COPs, and the more space heating that is performed, the better the expected COP."
19.7kW PV SE, VI, HM, EN & DW
Ripple 7kW WT & Gen to date 19MWh
42kWh LFPO4 storage
95kWh Heater storage
12kWh 210ltr HWT.
73kWh HI5
Deep insulation, air leak ct'd home
Zoned GCH & Hive 2
WBSx2
Low energy bulbs
Veg patches & fruit trees
User avatar
Joeboy
Posts: 8013
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 4:22 pm
Location: Inverurie

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#285

Post by Joeboy »

Within that same post in the comments section I found this.

https://community.openenergymonitor.org ... d/21891/20

I should probably have read it through before committing to buy but now at least I have my.own cop of 2 based on worry & fretting to monitor. :lol:
19.7kW PV SE, VI, HM, EN & DW
Ripple 7kW WT & Gen to date 19MWh
42kWh LFPO4 storage
95kWh Heater storage
12kWh 210ltr HWT.
73kWh HI5
Deep insulation, air leak ct'd home
Zoned GCH & Hive 2
WBSx2
Low energy bulbs
Veg patches & fruit trees
User avatar
Joeboy
Posts: 8013
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 4:22 pm
Location: Inverurie

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#286

Post by Joeboy »

Fintray wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 4:10 pm
Joeboy wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 3:24 pm
Fintray wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 9:36 am

I went MID metering as it is probably the most accurate available and will give you a true picture as to how your system is performing.
Thank you, I have asked for a price on the full bhuna. :D
The Openenergy monitor is MID metering.
Ah great, so I don't have a need to pony up for anything extra in the way of monitoring unless that's my thang?

Got this through from George,
"Robbie advised that we can provide you with the Open Energy Monitor and a connection to the web, at no extra charge. The 'full' OEM setup would necessitate another plumbed-in component, which would add cost and time, but if you're happy with the ability to compare SCOP online then that's no problem!"
19.7kW PV SE, VI, HM, EN & DW
Ripple 7kW WT & Gen to date 19MWh
42kWh LFPO4 storage
95kWh Heater storage
12kWh 210ltr HWT.
73kWh HI5
Deep insulation, air leak ct'd home
Zoned GCH & Hive 2
WBSx2
Low energy bulbs
Veg patches & fruit trees
User avatar
Joeboy
Posts: 8013
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 4:22 pm
Location: Inverurie

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#287

Post by Joeboy »

Got this quote for an OEM add on

"Open Energy Monitor Level 3 Heat Pump Monitoring setup.
BUNDLE INCLUDES
MID approved Modbus Electricity Meter
MID approved M-Bus Heat Meter
emonPi Web-connected data logger WiFi & Ethernet connectivity
Modbus RS485 reader (for electricity meter(s))
M-Bus reader (for heat meter)
Power supply and cables
10yrs of free emoncms.org data logging
Supplied and installed - £654.06 (zero VAT when installed as part of the heat pump job)."


Am I correct in saying you went for the lite version Iain as part of the install rather than all the above ?
19.7kW PV SE, VI, HM, EN & DW
Ripple 7kW WT & Gen to date 19MWh
42kWh LFPO4 storage
95kWh Heater storage
12kWh 210ltr HWT.
73kWh HI5
Deep insulation, air leak ct'd home
Zoned GCH & Hive 2
WBSx2
Low energy bulbs
Veg patches & fruit trees
User avatar
Fintray
Posts: 1524
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 6:37 pm
Location: Aberdeenshire

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#288

Post by Fintray »

Joeboy wrote: Fri Nov 01, 2024 5:40 am
Fintray wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 4:10 pm
Joeboy wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 3:24 pm

Thank you, I have asked for a price on the full bhuna. :D
The Openenergy monitor is MID metering.
Ah great, so I don't have a need to pony up for anything extra in the way of monitoring unless that's my thang?

Got this through from George,
"Robbie advised that we can provide you with the Open Energy Monitor and a connection to the web, at no extra charge. The 'full' OEM setup would necessitate another plumbed-in component, which would add cost and time, but if you're happy with the ability to compare SCOP online then that's no problem!"
By the sounds of that reply they are not intending to install a heat meter which you need to be able to calculate the COP.
For the couple of hundred quid or so I would go for the full kit but that is purely your decision, it would be a pain to then decide to get it fitted later.

This is the full kit https://shop.openenergymonitor.com/leve ... le-emonhp/, I see they are using a different model of heat meter now which now works out cheaper than what mine cost. :cat-tear:

Edit - Joe what you have noted in the previous post is what I installed.
3.87kWp PV
10.24kWp PV SolarEdge system
Tesla Powerwall 2
100 x 47mm Navitron tubes (still being installed!) Now likely to be removed for more PV.
MK2 PV router DHW diverter
Morso 5kW WBS
Vaillant AroTherm 10kW ASHP
Nissan Leaf
User avatar
Joeboy
Posts: 8013
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 4:22 pm
Location: Inverurie

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#289

Post by Joeboy »

Fintray wrote: Fri Nov 01, 2024 11:26 am
Joeboy wrote: Fri Nov 01, 2024 5:40 am
Fintray wrote: Thu Oct 31, 2024 4:10 pm

The Openenergy monitor is MID metering.
Ah great, so I don't have a need to pony up for anything extra in the way of monitoring unless that's my thang?

Got this through from George,
"Robbie advised that we can provide you with the Open Energy Monitor and a connection to the web, at no extra charge. The 'full' OEM setup would necessitate another plumbed-in component, which would add cost and time, but if you're happy with the ability to compare SCOP online then that's no problem!"
By the sounds of that reply they are not intending to install a heat meter which you need to be able to calculate the COP.
For the couple of hundred quid or so I would go for the full kit but that is purely your decision, it would be a pain to then decide to get it fitted later.

This is the full kit https://shop.openenergymonitor.com/leve ... le-emonhp/, I see they are using a different model of heat meter now which now works out cheaper than what mine cost. :cat-tear:

Edit - Joe what you have noted in the previous post is what I installed.
Cheers Iain, some Scaletrix set this is turning into! :lol:

Sorry about the heat meter dunt. You've been a great help, not sure I'd have stepped off the edge of indecision without you going first. 8-)
19 days to install commencing. :twisted:
19.7kW PV SE, VI, HM, EN & DW
Ripple 7kW WT & Gen to date 19MWh
42kWh LFPO4 storage
95kWh Heater storage
12kWh 210ltr HWT.
73kWh HI5
Deep insulation, air leak ct'd home
Zoned GCH & Hive 2
WBSx2
Low energy bulbs
Veg patches & fruit trees
User avatar
Joeboy
Posts: 8013
Joined: Mon May 31, 2021 4:22 pm
Location: Inverurie

Re: ASHP & triple glazing

#290

Post by Joeboy »

Still playing with the SH times and managed to end yesterday in profit.


Image
19.7kW PV SE, VI, HM, EN & DW
Ripple 7kW WT & Gen to date 19MWh
42kWh LFPO4 storage
95kWh Heater storage
12kWh 210ltr HWT.
73kWh HI5
Deep insulation, air leak ct'd home
Zoned GCH & Hive 2
WBSx2
Low energy bulbs
Veg patches & fruit trees
Post Reply